All Entries Tagged With: "NoCo lunch lady"
Thanksgiving cooking with a NoCo lunch lady

Mary Vitale (with her husband Paul) was the longtime cafeteria cook at St. Thomas More parish. Photo: Vitale Family Cookbook
Though my husband and I both attended Catholic grade school in North County, our experiences with cafeteria food were drastically different. At my school, Transfiguration, lunch was similar to eating at a gas station – Landshire sandwiches “cooked” by a heat lamp and served with the Hostess dessert of your choice. At Keith’s school, St. Thomas More in Bel-Ridge, lunch was more like a home-cooked feast.
Served fresh every day by a legion of volunteer moms, the cafeteria fare at STM included meatloaf, mashed potatoes, salads, pasta, and the infamous Weiner Winks – a gooey marriage of hot dogs and American cheese.
Most of the recipes were created by Mary Louise Vitale, whose work as the school’s cafeteria cook led to 29 years as a successful catering company owner. If you lived in the Normandy area and attended any school function/wedding/party between 1970 and 1999 (when St. Thomas More closed), chances are you ate and raved about Mary Vitale’s cooking.

Mary Vitale's Weiner Winks: so wrong they're right
It’s not fancy food by any means, but man is it good! So in honor of Thanksgiving and Mary Vitale herself (who’s still kicking…and cooking), here’s a classic lunch lady recipe for all to enjoy, courtesy of Mary Vitale Catering and the Vitale Family Cookbook:
Strawberry Jello Salad
two 6oz. boxes strawberry Jello
4 cups boiling water
20 oz. frozen strawberries
4-6 medium bananas, mashed with fork
1 cup chopped pecans
16 oz. sour cream
Dissolve the Jello in the boiling water. Stir in the strawberries and bananas. Pour HALF of the mixture into a 9×13 pan and chill in the refrigerator until firm. Add the pecans to the other half of the liquid Jello mixture; set aside. Spread the sour cream over the chilled Jello in the pan. Pour the remaining Jello mixture on top. Chill overnight. Serves 24.















Are you getting ready for the big day? NOCO is a proud sponsor of the 3rd annual Live Well Ferguson 5K